Abstract
It is possible to begin new teaching opportunities in a variety of ambulatory care venues and design these teaching and learning programmes using the SPICES approach to curriculum reform. In an ambulatory care teaching programme it is possible to stimulate more student-centred learning and to move away from clinician-focused teaching. Opportunities for integrated learning and problem solving can be provided and an inter-professional approach fostered. Learning in the clinical context can be structured to meet both students' needs and curriculum requirements. Finally, opportunities for elective studies can be taken by students with a particular interest in a topic encountered. Developing a new teaching programme in an ambulatory care venue provides an opportunity to introduce elements of the SPICES approach to learning. The new programme created can be a model of innovative teaching in a medical school wishing to develop a revised undergraduate curriculum.
-
Key Words: Ambulatory care, Curriculum, Teaching methods, Logbooks
INTRODUCTION
Thirty years after its original description, the SPICES model of educational strategies [
1] remains a key tool for reforming and organising the undergraduate medical curriculum. The key elements promoted in the SPICES model, student-centred learning, problem-based learning,integrated or inter-professional teaching, communitybased education, elective studies, and a systematic or planned approach, are now widely shared and accepted[
2]. Together these provide an alternative approach to a traditional curriculum with its teacher-centred, informationgathering, discipline-based, hospital-based, standardised programme and its opportunistic, apprenticeship-based learning (
Fig. 1). Medical schools with a reformed curriculum have incorporated aspects of the SPICES approach to various extents.
“Ambulatory care refers to any place where patients attend healthcare facilities without being admitted as in-patients” [
3]. Currently ambulatory care venues are under-recognised by medical schools as a teaching and learning resource. Arguments for introducing teaching opportunities in ambulatory care venues [
4] include:
1) The duration of hospital in-patient stay has decreased due to the current move to providing more ambulatory-based patient care.
2) Core clinical problems are now more likely to beseen out-with the traditional teaching hospital. Day-care venues can be more appropriate for student learning.
3) “When implemented properly, ambulatory care education is uniquely suited to meet the needs of students, practicing physicians and most importantly the patient” [
5].
4) Directives from governing bodies for medical schools or for licensing practitioners may also promote this change of emphasis.
VENUES FOR AMBULATORY CARE TEACHING
If we look at venues where ambulatory care teaching initiatives have been reported, we see how elements of the SPICES model have been used to create innovative teaching and learning programmes making the experience, on many occasions, preferable to conventional teaching with in-patients.
1. Traditional venues
In routine out-patient clinics a student-centred approach was introduced using structured logbooks to help students maximise their learning [
4].
In those hospital venues less commonly used for undergraduate teaching and in regional healthcare venues, opportunities for inter-professional teaching and for experience of healthcare in the wider community setting were identified [
6,
7].
Some schools have created dedicated teaching spaces and programmes. An Ambulatory Care Teaching Centre (ACTC) was used to deliver a student-centred programme with a systematic approach using systemsensitive volunteer patients. In this way students were enabled to integrate their learning with information acquired elsewhere [
8,
9]. In a regional Diagnostic and Treatment Centre (DTC) student learning was focussed on solving clinical problems encountered in community settings and opportunities were provided for student elective studies [
7]. Finally a simulated out-patient clinic where students received tutor feedback on a video recording of their encounter with standardised patients also provided an example of student-centred learning [
10].
USING THE SPICES MODEL
Medical schools wishing to provide new clinical teaching opportunities in an ambulatory care venue can be encouraged to use the SPICES model of educational strategies to create a programme with characteristics of a revised, undergraduate curriculum.
1. Student-centred learning
Student-centred learning can be promoted by the use of study guides [
9] or structured logbooks [
3]. These resources can direct students to learning outcomes related to the clinical problems being seen. A student-centred approach can be provided in the ACTC where tutors are free from the demands of patient care and interruptions. Students benefit from the unhurried environment, the personal tuition and from time to practise clinical or communication skills [
8].
Study guides or logbooks can provide diagnostic or management problems for students to solve based on the core clinical problems they will encounter [
7]. The emphasis is on problem-solving rather than information gathering.
Integrated learning can be facilitated when students in a systems-based course attend a clinical teaching session using system-sensitive patients invited from a bank of patient volunteers. Students can be stimulated to integrate their learning by reflecting on clinical or theoretical information encountered elsewhere in the course [
8]. Related information can also be made available in the session for reference or revision. Learning transfer is enhanced by providing tutors who teach in both dedicated teaching venues and routine clinical settings [
9]. Inter-professional teaching is readily available in the Day Surgery Unit where students
see patients on their journey from pre-assessment, to surgery and post-operative recovery, so encountering a variety of healthcare professionals [
4].
Moving student teaching to venues in the wider community such as the DTC [
7] or to community child development clinics [
6], allows students to gain experience in a wider range of common healthcare problems often more appropriate for undergraduates and with patients who may be more accessible than those in the teaching hospital.
Introducing student elective opportunities in ambulatory care venues moves learning away from a standardised/uniform programme to one which gives students a choice of further study in areas of interest. A 4-week rotation through a variety of specialties in out-patient clinics; the clinical investigation and radiology units; nurse or therapist-led procedure clinics; and the day surgery unit were appreciated by students who selected this option [
7]. Informally they reported an increased interest in rural-based practice as a result.
Structured logbooks are the key to delivering a systematic approach to clinical teaching in ambulatory care settings. They can ensure that students see the required range of core clinical problems and focus on appropriate learning objectives. Opportunistic exposure to clinical cases is avoided by using system-specific patients selected from a bank of patient volunteers invited to the ACTC teaching session so ensuring that the clinical cases seen match the students’ current theoretical course [
8].
CONCLUSION
The SPICES model of educational strategies remains as relevant today as 30 years ago wherever curriculum reform is required or where new approaches to teaching and learning are being introduced. Introducing new teaching opportunities in an ambulatory care teaching facility provides an opportunity to use the SPICES model to develop an innovative programme in a new location.It is possible to visualise a teaching programme or curriculum by plotting it on the SPICES spectrum and observing whether its use of any of the six strategies is more to one end of the spectrum than the other. Over time this position may change as further innovations are introduced.
In an ambulatory care teaching programme it is possible to stimulate more student-centred learning and to move away from clinician-focused teaching. Opportunities for integrated learning and problem solving can be provided and an inter-professional approach fostered. Learning in the clinical context can be structured to meet students’ needs and curriculum requirements. Finally, opportunities for elective studies can be taken by students with a particular interest in a topic.
Developing a new teaching programme in an ambulatory care venue provides an opportunity to introduce elements of the SPICES approach to learning. The new programme created can be a model of innovative teaching in a medical school wishing to develop a revised undergraduate curriculum.
Fig. 1.The SPICES Model of Educational Strategies [
1]
References
- 1. Harden RM, Sowden S, Dunn WR. Educational strategies in curriculum development: the SPICES model. Med Educ. 1984;18:284-297.
- 2. Harden RM, Laidlaw JM. Essential skills for a medical teacher: an introduction to teaching and learning in medicine. Edinburgh, UK: Churchill Livingstone; 2012.
- 3. In: Dent JA, Harden RM, eds. A practical guide for medical teachers. 4th ed. London, UK: Elsevier; 2013:Chapter 12, Ambulatory care teaching; p 93-102.
- 4. In: Walsh K, ed. Oxford textbook of medical education. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; 2013:Chapter 19, Learning in ambulatory care; p 221-232.
- 5. Fields SA, Usatine R, Steiner E. Teaching medical students in the ambulatory setting: strategies for success. JAMA. 2000;283:2362-2364.
- 6. Bardgett RJ, Dent JA. Teaching and learning in outpatients and beyond: how ambulatory care teaching can contribute to student learning in child health. Arch Dis Child Educ Pract Ed. 2011;96:148-152.
- 7. Dent J, Skene S, Nathwani D, Pippard M, Ponnamperuma G, Davis M. Design, implementation and evaluation of a medical education programme using the ambulatory diagnostic and treatment centre. Med Teach. 2007;29:341-345.
- 8. Dent JA, Angell-Preece HM, Ball HM, Ker JS. Using the Ambulatory Care Teaching Centre to develop opportunities for integrated learning. Med Teach. 2001;23:171-175.
- 9. Latta L, Tordoff D, Manning P, Dent J. Enhancing clinical skill development through an Ambulatory Medicine Teaching Programme: an evaluation study. Med Teach. 2013;35:648-654.
- 10. Myung SJ, Kang SH, Kim YS, Lee EB, Shin JS, Shin HY, Park WB. The use of standardized patients to teach medical students clinical skills in ambulatory care settings. Med Teach. 2010;32:e467-e470.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
- Integrating basic, clinical, and health system science in a medical neuroscience course of an integrated pre‐clerkship curriculum
Richard L. Goodwin, Asa C. Black, Thomas I. Nathaniel
Anatomical Sciences Education.2024; 17(2): 263. CrossRef - The continuing use of the SPICES model in ‘SAVOURING’ curriculum development
John A. Dent
Medical Teacher.2023; 45(7): 760. CrossRef - Medical Education in Costa Rica. From Flexner to COVID-19: Integrative Answers for Old and New Challenges
Jean Carlo Segura Aparicio, Lizbeth Salazar Sánchez, Alfredo Jesús López Dávila
Medical Science Educator.2023; 33(6): 1389. CrossRef - Training Medical Students in Cognitive, Intrapersonal, and Interpersonal Domain Competencies: Existing Challenges and Role of Medical Teachers
Saurabh RamBihariLal Shrivastava, Mira Ayu Duan Raharjo, Bayu Fajar Pratama, Tasi’ah Nashirah Nur, Nurul Maziyyah, Kresna Lintang Pratidina, Achcia Thema Maliny, Yanuarti Retnaningrum
Journal of the Scientific Society.2023; 50(3): 293. CrossRef - Implementation and Evaluation of a Faculty Development Program; an Essential Step for Curricular Change
Mennatallah Hassan Rizk, Asmaa Abdel Nasser, Rabab Abdel Ra’oof, Soha Rashed Aref, Wagdy Talaat
Journal of Ecophysiology and Occupational Health.2022; : 67. CrossRef
