Purpose Diagnostic errors contribute to patient safety risks, often arising from cognitive failures in clinical reasoning. Preceptorship is thought to improve residents’ clinical reasoning. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of a preceptorship program on clinical reasoning among pediatric residents.
Methods This randomized controlled trial was conducted from March 2025 to May 2025 at Dr. Soetomo General Academic Hospital, Surabaya, Indonesia. All pediatric residents were randomly allocated into two groups. The intervention group received a scheduled preceptorship program, while the control group continued with standard supervision. After 8 weeks, clinical reasoning skills were assessed using the Script Concordance Test (SCT). Data were analyzed using comparation test. End-of-program questionnaires were also reported.
Results Total 41 residents completed the study. Baseline characteristics did not differ between groups (p>0.05). Mean overall SCT scores ranged from 55% to 90% of the maximum possible score. Among 14 topics, hematology & oncology was the only topic that showed a significant difference in SCT scores between the intervention group (median, 14.28; interquartile range [IQR], 12.78–15.08) and the control group (median, 12.75; IQR, 11.49–13.63). Participants reported that preceptorship made learning more structured and interactive but noted barriers including busy preceptor schedules and lack of standardized teaching materials.
Conclusion The preceptorship program resulted in a significant improvement in only one topic, which may reflect suboptimal implementation of the intervention. Despite this, participants reported positive perceptions, indicating good acceptability. More intensive and consistent preceptorship may be required to achieve measurable improvements in clinical reasoning.
Purpose The introduction of community-based medical education would help improve the quality of primary care. This paper suggests learning objectives and an educational program for community-based medical education.
Methods The educational program was developed in a 1-day consensus workshop. Twenty experts, including faculty members from family medicine department of a college of medicine in Seoul and community-based preceptors, participated in the program. A needs-assessment survey was conducted among community-based preceptors before the workshop. Through this workshop, we derived learning objectives and a standardized curriculum for community-based medical education.
Results In the questionnaire before the workshop, community-based preceptors voiced concerns over the program’s potential costs and the time required for teaching. The learning objectives and educational programs derived from the workshop’s consensus were consistent with the characteristics of the primary care. Based on the results of this workshop, the joint expert team developed a standard educational program on two core topics: clinical teaching and mentoring.
Conclusion From this curriculum development process, participants could construct a more standardized curriculum for community-based medical education. Future studies are needed to evaluate the long-term outcomes of these educational programs, such as the learners’ satisfaction and achievement.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Current status and needs of community-based practice in public healthcare institutions among Korean medical schools: a cross-sectional study Songrim Kim, Bongeun Cha, Sun Young Kyung, So Jung Yune, Kyung Hye Park, Kwi Hwa Park Journal of Yeungnam Medical Science.2025; 42: 21. CrossRef
A Qualitative Study of the Experiences of Medical Students and Preceptor Physicians during Clinical Training at Regional Public Hospitals Kyung Hye Park, In Cheol Hwang, So Jung Yune, Kwi Hwa Park Korean Medical Education Review.2025; 27(2): 169. CrossRef
A preceptoria no ensino médico: desafios e reflexões sobre práticas pedagógicas e metodologias ativas André Felipe Guerle Tonso, Cristiana Carvalho Fernandes Caderno Pedagógico.2024; 21(13): e12706. CrossRef
Perception of Faculty toward Challenges in Teaching and the Role of Medical Education Workshops in Addressing Them: A Mixed-Methods Study Saurabh Shrivastava, Shivasakthy Manivasakan, Prateek Saurabh Shrivastava, Lavakumar Somu Avicenna Journal of Medicine.2022; 12(01): 021. CrossRef
Experiences and perspectives on patient-centered education of medical students in Korea Inji Yeom, Kiduk Kim, Junhwan Choi, Dong-Mi Yoo Korean Journal of Medical Education.2022; 34(4): 259. CrossRef
Gender and age group modified association of dental health indicators with total occlusal force among Korean elders Christine Hyun Jin Lee, Huong Vu, Hyun-Duck Kim BMC Oral Health.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Medical Students' Perception of Community-Based Education Research and Services (COBERS) In Mbarara University of Science and Technology. Ritah Naali Student's Journal of Health Research Africa.2021; 2(3): 14. CrossRef
Nursing and Medical Students’ Perceptions of the Rehabilitation Medicine Course Unit: A Case Study of Mbarara University of Science and Technology. Lillian Nabacwa Student's Journal of Health Research Africa.2021; 2(3): 11. CrossRef
In an effort to evaluate the usage of preceptorship in a department of family medicine, we analyzed the data which gathered during 10 months, from July 1990 to April 1991. The analyzed results were as follows ; 1. The number of precepting per preceptor was 3.5 during one day. 2. In the clinical learning, the residents needed instruction most frequently in the process for diagnosing the problems of their patients. 3. For the purpose of evaluating the teaching behavior of preceptors, we asked to 21 residents and 8 preceptors of the department who experienced the preceptorship for responding a questionnaire, which contained 30 questions. Residents perceived that the most contributable teaching behavior was "deals with students in a friendly, outgoing manner". Preceptors answered that behavior as "emphasizes problem solving approaches rather than solution per se". About the least contributable teaching behavior, residents and preceptors agreed that it was "emphasis on his/her personal research". For further improvement in clinical instruction and its evaluation, it would be necessary to develop a collaborative methodology for clinical instruction and to organize an ongoing professional communication.
First
Prev
